AIPsy-Affect: A Keyword-Free Clinical Stimulus Battery for Mechanistic Interpretability of Emotion in Language Models

arXiv cs.CL / 4/28/2026

📰 NewsDeveloper Stack & InfrastructureTools & Practical UsageModels & Research

Key Points

  • The paper highlights a key methodological confound in mechanistic interpretability of emotion in LLMs: stimuli that include emotion words make it unclear whether models detect the emotion itself or merely the presence of emotion-keyword tokens.
  • It introduces AIPsy-Affect, an openly released 480-item clinical stimulus battery with 192 keyword-free narrative vignettes for Plutchik’s eight primary emotions plus matched neutral controls designed to remove emotion-keyword cues.
  • The matched-pair design provides a strong guarantee for analyses like linear probing, activation patching, SAE feature analysis, causal ablation, and steering-vector extraction: differences between each affect item and its neutral match cannot be driven by emotion-word presence.
  • A three-method NLP “defense” evaluation (bag-of-words sentiment, an emotion lexicon, and a contextual transformer classifier) supports the intended property: shallow lexical methods only capture situational vocabulary, while contextual models detect affect but fail to reliably infer emotion categories without keywords.
  • AIPsy-Affect expands an earlier 96-item battery by 4× and is released under the MIT license, enabling more reliable downstream claims about emotion circuits and intervention targets in LLMs.

Abstract

Mechanistic interpretability research on emotion in large language models -- linear probing, activation patching, sparse autoencoder (SAE) feature analysis, causal ablation, steering vector extraction -- depends on stimuli that contain the words for the emotions they test. When a probe fires on "I am furious", it is unclear whether the model has detected anger or detected the word "furious". The two readings have very different consequences for every downstream claim about emotion circuits, features, and interventions. We release AIPsy-Affect, a 480-item clinical stimulus battery that removes the confound at the stimulus level: 192 keyword-free vignettes evoking each of Plutchik's eight primary emotions through narrative situation alone, 192 matched neutral controls that share characters, setting, length, and surface structure with the affect surgically removed, plus moderate-intensity and discriminant-validity splits. The matched-pair structure supports linear probing, activation patching, SAE feature analysis, causal ablation, and steering vector extraction under a strong methodological guarantee: any internal representation that distinguishes a clinical item from its matched neutral cannot be doing so on the basis of emotion-keyword presence. A three-method NLP defense battery -- bag-of-words sentiment, an emotion-category lexicon, and a contextual transformer classifier -- confirms the property: bag-of-words methods see only situational vocabulary, and a contextual classifier detects affect (p < 10^-15) but cannot identify the category (5.2% top-1 vs. 82.5% on a keyword-rich control). AIPsy-Affect extends our earlier 96-item battery (arXiv:2603.22295) by a factor of four and is released openly under MIT license.