Article URL: https://www.diabettech.com/i-asked-ai-to-count-my-carbs-27000-times-it-couldnt-give-me-the-same-answer-twice/
Comments URL: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47947490
Points: 165
# Comments: 199
He asked AI to count carbs 27000 times. It couldn't give the same answer twice
Hacker News / 4/29/2026
💬 OpinionSignals & Early TrendsIdeas & Deep Analysis
Key Points
- The article describes an experiment where the author asked an AI system to count carbohydrate amounts for their meals 27,000 times to test whether it would produce consistent results.
- The AI reportedly failed the consistency test, often giving different answers on repeated requests rather than returning the same carb count each time.
- The outcome highlights limitations in reliability and repeatability for AI when used in high-stakes, health-related decision support.
- The piece implies that users should not treat AI-generated numeric outputs as deterministic without validation, especially in diabetes and nutrition contexts.
- It uses the experiment as a cautionary example for trusting AI in medical-adjacent tasks without adequate accuracy checks and safeguards.
Related Articles
How I Use AI Agents to Maintain a Living Knowledge Base for My Team
Dev.to
IK_LLAMA now supports Qwen3.5 MTP Support :O
Reddit r/LocalLLaMA
Indian Developers: How to Build AI Side Income with $0 Capital in 2026
Dev.to
Vertical SaaS for Startups 2026: Building a Niche AI-First Product
Dev.to
Vertical SaaS for Startups in 2026: The Complete Guide to Building a Niche AI-First Product
Dev.to
