AI Navigate

ICLR 2026 oral with 2 rejects, 1 borderline reject

Reddit r/MachineLearning / 3/20/2026

📰 NewsIdeas & Deep AnalysisModels & Research
Read original →
共有:

Key Points

  • ICLR 2026 featured an oral presentation for a paper that initially received two rejects and one borderline reject, prompting surprise among participants.
  • The program committee noted initial scores of 8/4/2/2 and suggested the final score should have been above 6, highlighting a potential mismatch between early reviews and final outcomes.
  • The claim that most reviewers do not update their scores is cited as making the AC's remark unusual, pointing to possible inconsistencies in the scoring process.
  • The discussion is linked to OpenReview and Reddit conversations, illustrating ongoing debates about peer-review transparency and fairness in AI conference decisions.

https://openreview.net/forum?id=BlSH7gNQSq

I'm just surprised that a paper with 2 rejects and 1 borderline reject (out of 4 scores) would end up being an oral. The AC says:

Initial ratings came as 8/4/2/2. While we cannot be sure how reviewers may have updated their scores, I'd expect a final score above 6.

Considering most reviewers do not update their scores, this is a very odd statement.

submitted by /u/WhiteBear2018
[link] [comments]

関連おすすめサービス

※当サイトはアフィリエイト広告を利用しています
🎧

Notta搭載AI議事録イヤホン ZENCHORD1

AI時代の仕事術。Notta搭載で会議の議事録を自動生成するスマートイヤホン。

🎙️

AI搭載ボイスレコーダー Plaud

世界100万人が愛用。AIで文字起こし・要約を自動化するボイスレコーダー。

🖼️

画像高画質化AIツール Aiarty Image Enhancer

AIで画像を高画質化。写真・イラストを簡単にアップスケール。